W:
2 (40%)
D:
0 (0%)
L:
3 (60%)
19 Oct 2025
New York City vs
Seattle Sounders
1-2
05 Oct 2025
Philadelphia Union vs
New York City
1-0
28 Sep 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
New York City
2-3
25 Sep 2025
New York City vs
Inter Miami
0-4
20 Sep 2025
New York City vs
Charlotte
2-0
W:
2 (50%)
D:
0 (0%)
L:
2 (50%)
19 Oct 2025
New York City vs
Seattle Sounders
1-2
25 Sep 2025
New York City vs
Inter Miami
0-4
20 Sep 2025
New York City vs
Charlotte
2-0
18 Sep 2025
New York City vs
Columbus Crew
3-2
W:
2 (67%)
D:
0 (0%)
L:
1 (33%)
05 Oct 2025
Philadelphia Union vs
New York City
1-0
28 Sep 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
New York City
2-3
14 Sep 2025
Chicago Fire vs
New York City
1-3